Like Father, Like Son, Like You (Is God a Monster)?
In John 5, at the Pool of Bethesda (meaning “House of Mercy”), Jesus heals one “invalid” among “a multitude of invalids,” all competing for Mercy — that is Unconditional Love. Imagine if you were one of the other invalids: You might ask, “Is God some sort of Monster?” “The Jews” — as John, the Jew, calls them — get angry, for this happened on the Sabbath. And we wonder: “Are they emotional invalids or maybe monsters?” Jesus then finds the invalid, now healed and walking in the old stone temple, and tells him to stop sinning. And He tells the Jews, “My Father has been working until now and I am working.” And they sought “all the more to kill him” because he referred to God as his own Father. It seems that they were all invalids competing for Unconditional Love, Daddy Love.
Well, if God only heals some, He does seem to be rather mean, doesn’t He?
And if God only saves some, blessing them with endless bliss, while damning others to endless conscious torment, doesn’t that make Him something of a monster?
This is the sixth line of “The Statement of Faith” for The National Association of Evangelicals: “We believe in the resurrection of both the saved and the lost; they that are saved unto the resurrection of life and they that are lost unto the resurrection of damnation.”
It’s a bit strange on the face of it, for it seems to be a confession of faith in the inability of, or lack of desire to, seek and save “the Lost” on the part of Jesus, who came “to seek and to save the lost.” And yet, they get this language from what Jesus says to these folks in the temple in John 5:29, according to the translators of the King James version of the Bible in 1611. “All that are in the graves shall hear his voice and come forth; they that have done good, unto the resurrection of life; and they that have done evil unto the resurrection of damnation.”
About half of the institutional church would argue that this is God’s free choice. And most of the other half would argue that this is our free choice. But either way, it would seem that God is something of a monster — endless bliss for some and endless torture for others.
We watched a video of a man turning into a beast, and I said, “Imagine if that man was your father.” I’m not a healthcare professional, but I think it’s safe to say that if you only suspected that your father was a werewolf, that he had two natures, it would have a profound effect upon your daily life. You might appear to be very obedient, respectful, well-adjusted, and compliant. And yet, your heart would be emotionally isolated, trapped within a prison of fear, and unable to love.
In the 2nd century, Marcion the heretic taught that the God of the Old Testament was different than that God of the New. In the 4th century, Augustine taught that God was Mercy and not Mercy, which he defined as “Justice.” In 20th century America, it became common to portray God the Father as having to kill God the Son in order to feel better about you... because God the Son is merciful, and God the Father is Just (not merciful).
If you find yourself competing for Mercy, worried that God might be two instead of One, wondering if He might just be a monster or if you, a little child, had the power to turn him into a monster... you need more than conventional therapy, self-help books, practical application points, rules, or more law; you need the Gospel.
In John 5:19, in the old stone temple, surrounded by spiritual invalids all competing for unconditional love, Jesus preaches the Gospel. “The Son can do nothing of himself, but only what he sees the Father doing.” Could the Son deliver himself up for crucifixion if the Father did not deliver himself up for Crucifixion? Could God the Son “will” what God the Father does not will? I don’t think so. But once in a garden, He did pray, “Not as I will, but as you will.” Perhaps He is Good will having descended into my bad will and willing what I cannot. Perhaps He actually is my righteousness.
He continues, John 5:21, “For as the Father raises the dead and gives them life (That must be his judgment... Dead things don’t make judgments), so also the son gives life to whom he will. For the Father judges no one but gives all [the] judgment to the son.”
“All judgment” — That’s all decisions, all choices; that’s running the universe.
We like to think we have “free will” because we can move our own bag of dust, our body. But imagine if you had “free will” like God has “free will”! All creation is his bag of dust, like his body. If God the Father freely wills to give his free will to his Son, He’s hardly a stingy, self-centered father. And now listen to God the Son: “The Spirit of Truth will glorify me, for he will take what is mine (all judgment, Free Will) and declare it to you. All that the Father has is mine” (John 16:14-15). Like Father, like Son, Like You,
You are predestined for an entirely free will, God’s will, Love. . . and “all things with Him.”
John 5:24, “Truly, truly, I say to you, whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life [The life of the age]. He does not come into judgment...”
But what is Judgment if God and Jesus don’t judge? In John 8, Jesus says “I judge no one. Yet if I do judge, my judgment is true, for it is not I alone who judge but I and the Father who sent me (That sounds like a communion of non-judgment that is “the Judgment”)...when you have lifted up the Son of Man, you will see that I Am”
How could I Am that I Am “make” judgments? We make judgments in space and time. Anytime He seems to make a judgment, it’s the manifestation of the Judgment that has always been made. “This is the Judgment,” said Jesus in John 3, “The LIGHT.” “NOW is the Judgment,” said Jesus in John 12. LIGHT is eternal (A photon doesn’t experience the passage of time.) And NOW is the point in which eternity touches time, and we make judgments, or, I should say, the Eternal Judgment of God makes us. “God is Light” and “Jesus is the Light of the World,” writes John in 1 John. Jesus is the Judgment of God.
John 5:24, “Truly, truly, I say to you, whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life. He does not come into judgment but has passed from death [in] to [the] life.”
If you believe, you confess that you were dead (dead things have very bad judgment.) And if you don’t believe, you are dead and trapped in Hades, for dead things can’t do anything until something is done to them.
John 5:25-27, “Truly, truly, I say to you, an hour is coming, and is now here, when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear (That is, the dead) will live. (That’s God’s Judgment: The dead will live. It’s the second time He’s said it). For as the Father has life in himself, so he has granted the Son also to have life in himself. And he has given him authority [poiein: to do] judgment, because he is the Son of Man.”
God is his Father. Man (that’s us) is his mother. He is faith in our faithlessness, Hope in our hopelessness, Love in our lovelessness, Righteousness in our unrighteousness, Grace in our sin, Good Judgment born out of our bad judgment, and so, saving us from our invalid selves.
John 5:28-29, “Do not marvel at this, for an hour is coming when all who are in the tombs will hear his voice and come out, those who have done good [in] to the resurrection of life, and those who have [practiced] evil [in] to the resurrection of judgment.”
“Those who have done good”: They resurrect into Life. Why? Because they have already believed, which means they’ve already been judged. To believe is to lose your life and find it in Jesus.
“Those who have practiced evil”: They resurrect into Judgment. And what is the Judgment? Well, He just preached it. The dead will live. It’s the death of death which is The Life. Jesus is The Life. “I know that my Father’s commandment is eternal life,” said Jesus, the Life (John 12:50).
John 5:29 is perhaps the most hopeful verse in all the Bible. Nobody gets away with anything: We must all die with Christ. And nobody misses out on anything: We must all live in Christ with God.
And nobody is exactly like anybody else, for God is writing the story of His Mercy into the unique disobedience of each one of us, his vessels, his children.
John 5:29 is perhaps the most hopeful verse in all the Bible, and yet when the translators of the King James Version translated the last word of John 5:29, they just changed the word “Judgment” (krisis in Greek) into “Damnation” (katakrisis in Greek). And institutions, like the National Association of Evangelicals, major seminaries, and denominations, entirely capable of understanding the Greek, have not corrected this obvious mistranslation, but instead have required conscription to this statement of faith in God’s inability, or lack of desire, to save.
And so we must ask, “Why would we do such a thing?” Perhaps we are the monsters? Maybe God is not two, but one? “Hear, O Israel the Lord our God, the Lord is One.” That’s the command. “And you will Love...” That’s the Promise.
Perhaps God is not two, but one. And each of us is not one, but two — a false self (an in-valid self), that listens to the father of lies and so thinks it is its own creator … and a true self, that knows he or she is the creation of God, “our Father.”
Don’t listen to the dragon, for he would turn you into a monster (a man trapped in a beast).
Believe the Gospel. He is the Judgment of God.