161 avsnitt
- Did Plato Believe Society Needs Lies? | Agnes Callard & Tim Blake Nelson on the Noble Lie
👉 FULL Episode Available Here for Classical Wisdom Members: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/p/the-noble-lie-platos-most-dangerous
👉 Become a Classical Wisdom Member: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/subscribe?coupon=b28f7da1
What if the stories holding our society together aren't actually true?
And what if the ancient Greek philosopher Plato understood this more than 2,000 years ago?
In Book III of Plato's Republic, Socrates introduces one of the most controversial ideas in Western philosophy: the Noble Lie.
It's a founding myth designed to convince citizens that they have different kinds of metals in their souls—gold, silver, bronze, or iron—and that these differences help determine their roles in society.
But why would a philosopher devoted to truth propose deliberately deceiving people?
And could society function without such myths?
In this episode of Classical Wisdom Speaks, host Anya Leonard is joined by Agnes Callard, philosopher at the University of Chicago and author of Open Socrates, and Tim Blake Nelson, acclaimed actor, writer, director, and classics graduate.
Together, they explore Plato's Republic, the nature of political deception, and the invisible assumptions that shape our everyday lives.
Agnes offers a fascinating interpretation of the Noble Lie: perhaps Plato recognized that much of what we consider natural or inevitable about society is actually constructed through shared beliefs and conventions.
Tim considers the role of organizing myths in human civilization, from religion to political institutions, while questioning whether these narratives are necessary for collective life.
But the conversation doesn't stop at politics.
Are we telling little lies in almost every social interaction?
Agnes suggests that even ordinary conversations depend on shared pretenses that we rarely notice.
The discussion also explores Plato's strict educational system, whether governments should influence our health and lifestyle choices, and whether political leaders should be tested for wisdom and character before assuming power.
From ancient Athens to modern social media, the questions are remarkably relevant.
Who decides what society should believe? Can a lie ever serve the common good? And how do we distinguish necessary social conventions from dangerous political deception?
Join us for a thought-provoking conversation about Plato, truth, power, and the stories we live by.
⏱️ Timestamps
00:00 Meet Agnes Callard and Tim Blake Nelson
01:28 Exploring Plato's Republic
02:09 Should the state control our lives?
05:57 Plato's City of Pigs
07:20 Freedom versus conformity
11:10 Health, fitness, and the soul
15:30 Should leaders be tested?
18:15 Education and social hierarchy
21:34 What is the Noble Lie?
22:13 Why societies need shared myths
25:01 Are all social systems built on lies?
27:16 The lies we tell every day
30:43 Why read Plato so closely?
31:28 Tim on the value of philosophy
33:17 Agnes on reading The Republic
37:24 Plato's troubling political legacy
38:38 Final reflections
What Do You Think?
Can a society function without shared myths—or are some forms of deception unavoidable?
And should political leaders ever be allowed to tell a lie for the supposed greater good?
Share your thoughts in the comments!
👉 Subscribe to Classical Wisdom Speaks for conversations about ancient philosophy, Greek history, political thought, and timeless ideas that continue to shape our world.
👉 Discover our free newsletter and more ancient wisdom: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com
👉 Watch Tim & Agnes' podcast, Exploring the Greats: https://ExploringTheGreats.com
About Our Guests
Agnes Callard is a philosopher and professor at the University of Chicago. She is the author of Open Socrates and explores questions of ethics, aspiration, and the Socratic philosophical tradition.
Tim Blake Nelson is an actor, director, writer, and classics graduate of Brown University. His films include O Brother, Where Art Thou? and The Ballad of Buster Scruggs.
Together, Agnes and Tim host a video podcast dedicated to Plato's Republic as part of Exploring the Greats, a series devoted to close readings and discussions of major works of literature and philosophy, you can find it at ExploringTheGreats.com - Was Athens' Golden Age Really Golden? | Pericles, Democracy & Empire
Was ancient Athens truly the birthplace of democracy and civilization or was its famous Golden Age built on conquest, inequality, and imperial power?
When we think of Pericles and the Golden Age of Athens, we imagine the Parthenon, Socrates, Greek tragedy, extraordinary art, and the birth of Western democracy.
But behind this remarkable cultural flourishing lies a far more complicated story.
How democratic was Athens really? Who paid for its greatness? And was Pericles a visionary statesman—or a brilliant demagogue?
In this special Classical Wisdom event, host Anya Leonard welcomes two distinguished scholars of ancient Greece:
Paul Cartledge, historian of ancient Greek democracy and author of Pericles: Statesman, Demagogue, Eccentric, and Armand D'Angour, Oxford classicist and author of Socrates in Love: The Making of a Philosopher.
Together, they challenge the traditional image of fifth-century BCE Athens and explore the extraordinary achievements—and troubling contradictions—of its most celebrated political leader.
Pericles was born into an aristocratic family, yet became a champion of Athenian democracy. He helped expand political participation while simultaneously defending an empire that demanded tribute and obedience from its allies.
Under his leadership, Athens built the Parthenon, became a center of art and intellectual life, and developed a political culture built around public debate and persuasion.
But its prosperity came at a cost.
The Athenian Empire exerted power over other Greek city-states, while women, enslaved people, and noncitizens remained excluded from democratic decision-making.
The discussion also examines the remarkable Aspasia of Miletus, Pericles' influential partner, whose intellectual and social position challenges our assumptions about women in classical Athens.
And then there is the question of war.
Did Pericles' policies make the Peloponnesian War inevitable? Was he right to confront Sparta, or did his commitment to Athenian supremacy help bring about the destruction of the world he had helped create?
Drawing on Thucydides, Plutarch, ancient political institutions, and modern historical scholarship, Paul and Armand explore how charisma, rhetoric, ambition, and imperial power shaped Athenian democracy.
The result is a fascinating reconsideration of one of history's most influential—and most contradictory—civilizations.
Was the Golden Age of Athens a triumph of democracy, or a warning about what happens when democracy becomes an empire?
Timestamps:
00:00 Pericles and the myth of the Golden Age
02:11 Meet Paul Cartledge and Armand D'Angour
04:14 Who was Pericles?
10:49 What made Athens' Golden Age?
15:04 Statesman or demagogue?
21:02 Why was Pericles controversial?
25:26 Ostracism and democratic accountability
28:01 Can democracy coexist with empire?
35:43 Pericles and imperial power
48:01 Aspasia: the woman behind Pericles
01:05:03 Athenian identity and citizenship
01:11:00 What caused the Peloponnesian War?
01:21:02 Audience Q&A
01:23:00 The plague and Pericles' downfall
01:35:00 Democracy, duty, and civic life
01:49:00 Final reflections
What Do You Think?
Can a society truly call itself democratic while ruling over others?
And do you think Pericles deserves his reputation as one of history's greatest statesmen?
Share your thoughts in the comments!
👉 Explore Classical Wisdom's free newsletter, in-depth articles, events, and resources: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/
👉 Subscribe to Classical Wisdom for more conversations about ancient history, Greek philosophy, democracy, mythology, and the ideas that continue to shape our world.
Guests:
Paul Cartledge is a leading historian of ancient Greece and a senior research fellow at Clare College, Cambridge. His work explores Sparta, Athenian democracy, Greek politics, and classical civilization. He is the author of Pericles: Statesman, Demagogue, Eccentric.
Armand D'Angour is Professor of Classics at the University of Oxford and Fellow and Tutor at Jesus College. His research explores ancient Greek culture, philosophy, music, and intellectual history. He is the author of Socrates in Love: The Making of a Philosopher. - What Do We REALLY Know About Pythagoras?
👉 FULL Episode Available Here for Classical Wisdom Members: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/p/who-was-pythagoras-really
👉 Become a Classical Wisdom Member: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/subscribe?coupon=b28f7da1
Was Pythagoras really a mathematical genius—or one of the ancient world's most mysterious spiritual leaders?
Most of us know Pythagoras for his famous theorem. But behind the mathematics lies a far stranger story involving reincarnation, secret societies, sacred numbers, cosmic music, and extraordinary claims of supernatural powers.
So who was the real Pythagoras?
In this episode of Classical Wisdom Speaks, host Anya Leonard welcomes Christoph Riedweg, professor of classical philology and Greek studies at the University of Zurich and author of Pythagoras: His Life, Teaching, and Influence.
Together, they investigate the historical Pythagoras and the legends that have surrounded him for more than 2,500 years.
Was he a philosopher, scientist, religious reformer, political adviser—or all of these at once?
Christoph explains why separating historical fact from legend is extraordinarily difficult. Even ancient writers disagreed about Pythagoras, portraying him either as a remarkable sage or as a charismatic charlatan.
And while Pythagoras is celebrated for his mathematical discoveries, some of the ideas attributed to him were already known in ancient Babylonia.
But mathematics was only one part of his worldview.
Pythagoras reportedly believed in metempsychosis, the transmigration of souls between human beings and animals. One early account even describes him recognizing the soul of a deceased friend in a puppy.
His followers formed a distinctive community in Croton, southern Italy, combining philosophy, religious practices, initiation rituals, and political influence.
At the heart of their thinking was a radical idea: number is the fundamental principle of reality.
The mathematical ratios that produce musical harmony might also explain the structure of the cosmos, the human soul, and even moral qualities such as justice.
Anya and Christoph also explore Pythagoras' connections to Orpheus, Orphic mystery traditions, ancient Egypt, Plato, and the Greek understanding of the afterlife.
Was Pythagoras ahead of his time—or have centuries of legend transformed him into someone he never was?
Discover the remarkable figure behind the theorem and why his ideas continue to fascinate us today.
Key Topics:
Who was the historical Pythagoras?
Pythagoras: mathematician, philosopher, or mystic?
The origins of the Pythagorean theorem
Ancient Babylonian mathematics
Reincarnation and transmigration of souls
Pythagoras and the Pythagorean brotherhood
Ancient Greek philosophy and the natural philosophers
Heraclitus' criticism of Pythagoras
Why the Pythagoreans believed everything was number
The music of the spheres and cosmic harmony
Orpheus, Orphism, and mystery religions
Ancient Egyptian influences on Greek philosophy
Plato and the legacy of Pythagoreanism
⏱️ Timestamps:
00:00 Introducing Christoph Riedweg
00:45 Who was the real Pythagoras?
01:11 Separating history from legend
01:49 The famous theorem and Babylonian mathematics
03:01 Music and the harmony of the spheres
04:57 How historians investigate Pythagoras
05:33 The first Greek philosophers
07:52 Pythagoras: scientist or spiritual leader?
09:40 Ancient criticism of Pythagoras
10:00 Reincarnation and the soul of a puppy
12:01 Charisma, miracles, and religious authority
13:20 The Pythagorean community in Croton
15:37 Heraclitus versus Pythagoras
18:57 Was there a coherent Pythagorean philosophy?
19:17 Why everything is number
22:51 The music of the spheres
25:36 Pythagoras and Orpheus
27:47 The Derveni Papyrus and Orphic traditions
29:12 Gold tablets and the afterlife
32:48 Memory, reincarnation, and the Underworld
40:05 Pythagoras' extraordinary legacy
44:01 Ethics and the Golden Verses
49:15 Why classical education still matters
What Do You Think?
Was Pythagoras primarily a scientist, a philosopher, or a religious leader?
And does his mysterious reputation make him more fascinating—or more difficult to understand?
Share your thoughts in the comments!
👉 Subscribe to Classical Wisdom Speaks for conversations about ancient Greek philosophy, history, mythology, and the ideas that shaped our world.
👉 Explore ancient wisdom and join our free newsletter: ClassicalWisdom.com
👉 Buy Christoph Riedweg's book Pythagoras: His Life, Teaching, and Influence. https://www.amazon.com.br/Pythagoras-Christoph-Riedweg/dp/0801442400
About Christoph Riedweg
Christoph Riedweg is a scholar of classical philology and Greek studies at the University of Zurich. His research explores ancient Greek philosophy, religion, and literature. - The Classical History of the Undead | Watch the FULL, EXTENDED EPISODE on Substack!
👉 FULL Episode Available Here for Classical Wisdom Members: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/p/is-burning-corpses-worse-than-burning
👉 Become a Classical Wisdom Member: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/subscribe?coupon=b28f7da1
What's the Difference Between a Saint and a Vampire?
And what if the real history of vampires is far stranger than anything in Dracula?
Long before Bram Stoker created his famous fictional vampire, people across the world feared that the dead could return to harm the living.
But these weren't necessarily blood-drinking aristocrats with sharp teeth. They were something more unsettling: ordinary corpses believed to retain a mysterious life force—even after burial.
In this episode of Classical Wisdom Speaks, host Anya Leonard welcomes John Blair, Emeritus Professor of Medieval History and Archaeology at the University of Oxford, to discuss his book Killing the Dead: Vampire Epidemics from Mesopotamia to the New World.
Together, they uncover the extraordinary history of the dangerous dead, exploring ancient beliefs, medieval folklore, archaeological discoveries, and the social fears that gave rise to vampire epidemics.
Why did some communities dig up corpses, drive nails through their bodies, or bury suspected vampires face down?
Why could an unusually well-preserved body be interpreted as evidence of either a saint or a vampire?
And why did fears of the undead often intensify during periods of plague, religious upheaval, and political instability?
From ancient Mesopotamia and the Greco-Roman world to medieval England, Serbia, and nineteenth-century America, John explains how beliefs about the restless dead emerged in different societies—and what they reveal about the people who held them.
The conversation also explores the surprising relationship between Christianity, resurrection, and vampire folklore, including medieval accounts of walking corpses and archaeological evidence from the late Roman world.
But perhaps the most intriguing question is psychological.
John argues that vampire epidemics could offer frightened communities a way to explain catastrophe, identify scapegoats, and regain a sense of control.
Were vampires really monsters—or did they reflect humanity's deepest fears about death, disease, and uncertainty?
Discover the forgotten history behind one of the world's most enduring supernatural beliefs.
Key Topics:
The real history of vampires and the undead
Why Dracula differs from historical vampire beliefs
Ancient Mesopotamian and Greco-Roman traditions
Archaeological evidence of restrained corpses
Vampire epidemics in medieval Europe
Why plagues and social upheaval fueled vampire fears
Burial rituals, cremation, and the dangerous dead
Saints, vampires, and incorrupt bodies
Christianity, resurrection, and medieval folklore
Vampire beliefs in Serbia, Greece, and England
How literature transformed the modern vampire
Scapegoating, fear, and the psychology of superstition
⏱️ Timestamps:
00:00 What is a vampire?
01:01 Defining the dangerous dead
03:21 Why vampire beliefs matter
04:41 Understanding the past on its own terms
06:37 Spirits and animated corpses
07:55 What makes a corpse dangerous?
08:45 The cat that creates a vampire
10:20 Plague, trauma, and scapegoating
11:45 Vampires in ancient Greece and Rome
13:13 Archaeological evidence of restrained corpses
15:00 Cremation and burial
16:08 Why corpses appear undecayed
17:40 Saints versus vampires
19:34 Vampire epidemics and social fear
22:07 How societies deal with death
24:26 Christianity and the undead
27:47 From folklore to Dracula
30:07 How Dracula changed vampire beliefs
31:00 Why the undead fascinate us
32:47 Final thoughts
What Do You Think?
Why do you think so many different cultures developed beliefs about the dangerous dead?
And what is more frightening: the idea that corpses could return to life, or the lengths people were willing to go to stop them?
Share your thoughts in the comments!
👉 Sign up for our free newsletter for more ancient mythology, history, literature and philosophy: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/subscribe?coupon=b28f7da1
👉 Buy "Killing the Dead" by John Blair: https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691224794/killing-the-dead
About John Blair
John Blair is Emeritus Professor of Medieval History and Archaeology at the University of Oxford and a Fellow of The Queen's College, Oxford. He is the author of Killing the Dead: Vampire Epidemics from Mesopotamia to the New World, which investigates the history of beliefs in dangerous corpses across different cultures and centuries. - What Can Ancient Epics Teach Us About Death? | Homer, Lost Classics & Greek Tragedy
What can the greatest stories of ancient Greece teach us about death, and how to live?
Thousands of years ago, Greek poets and playwrights were exploring questions we still struggle with today.
Is a short life of glory better than a long, ordinary one? What do we owe the dead? And how do we make sense of grief, loss, and mortality?
In this episode of Classical Wisdom Speaks, host Anya Leonard welcomes Classical Wisdom's resident classicist Ben Potter to explore how ancient Greek literature confronted death: from Homer's Iliad and Odyssey, to the lost Aethiopis, and the tragedies of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides.
In the Iliad, death is everywhere. Warriors lie unburied on the battlefield, Achilles is consumed by rage, and the ghost of Patroclus begs for the funeral rites that will allow him to find peace.
Yet the epic's conclusion offers something unexpected: a powerful moment of shared humanity when Priam comes to Achilles to reclaim the body of his son Hector.
The lost Aethiopis, part of the Trojan Epic Cycle, continues the story with the arrival of Memnon and the Amazon queen Penthesilea, whose death at Achilles' hands raises questions about honor, love, and the treatment of fallen enemies.
Meanwhile, in the Odyssey, Odysseus encounters the spirits of the dead. The forgotten sailor Elpenor pleads for burial, while Achilles, who sacrificed a long life for everlasting fame, offers a strikingly different perspective on heroic glory.
Was his sacrifice worth it?
Beyond Homer, the great Greek tragedians returned to these myths to explore conflicts between family, divine law, justice, and death. Works such as Antigone, Oedipus at Colonus, and Hippolytus reveal how ancient audiences grappled with questions that remain relevant today.
Anya and Ben also examine the historical world behind the literature, including Bronze Age burial customs, Mycenaean tombs, ritual pollution, and the Greek Underworld.
Are these ancient epics simply tales of heroes and gods, or timeless reflections on what it means to be human?
Key Topics:
What ancient Greek literature teaches us about death
Homer's Iliad and Odyssey
Achilles, Patroclus, Hector, and the meaning of honor
The lost Aethiopis, Memnon, and Penthesilea
The Trojan Epic Cycle and lost Greek classics
Odysseus, Elpenor, and the Underworld
Achilles' choice between glory and long life
Death and burial in Greek tragedy
Sophocles, Euripides, and Aeschylus
Antigone, Hippolytus, and Oedipus at Colonus
Ancient Greek funeral rituals and Mycenaean tombs
Hades, Tartarus, and the Elysian Fields
Grief, mortality, and the duty to honor the dead
⏱️ Timestamps:
00:00 Introducing Ben Potter
00:46 Death in Homer and tragedy
01:19 Ancient Greek literary history
03:16 The Bronze Age world of Homer
04:12 Greek funeral rituals
06:31 Death and ritual pollution
09:49 Euripides' Hippolytus
11:11 Mycenaean tombs
13:29 Death in the Iliad
16:18 Patroclus' ghost and Achilles
17:45 Hector, Priam, and burial
19:05 The lost Aethiopis
20:42 Penthesilea and Achilles
22:42 Death in the Odyssey
23:46 Elpenor's plea for burial
26:19 Odysseus and the dead
28:19 Achilles and the price of glory
29:11 Hades and the afterlife
32:12 The Greek tragedians
What Do You Think? Which ancient Greek story offers the most powerful lesson about death?
Is it Achilles mourning Patroclus, Priam reclaiming Hector, Odysseus encountering the dead, or Antigone's struggle over burial?
And what can these ancient works still teach us about grief and mortality?
Share your thoughts in the comments!
👉 Sign up for Classical Wisdom's free newsletter for more conversations about ancient literature, Greek mythology, philosophy, and history: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/subscribe?coupon=b28f7da1
GUEST:
Ben Potter is a classical scholar, longtime Classical Wisdom contributor, and creator of the Essential Greeks course. With expertise in Homer and ancient Greek theater, he explores how classical literature continues to illuminate the human experience.
Fler podcasts i Historia
Trendiga poddar i Historia
Om Classical Wisdom Speaks
A Podcast dedicated to bringing ancient wisdom to modern minds. This podcast is provided by Classical Wisdom, to learn more check out www.classicalwisdom.com
Podcast-webbplatsLyssna på Classical Wisdom Speaks, Seriemördarpodden och många andra poddar från världens alla hörn med radio.se-appen

Hämta den kostnadsfria radio.se-appen
- Bokmärk stationer och podcasts
- Strömma via Wi-Fi eller Bluetooth
- Stödjer Carplay & Android Auto
- Många andra appfunktioner




































